Panels

Building a desirable future through computer graphics and interactive techniques starts with you and your contributions to and participation in SIGGRAPH 2024. We are excited that you are submitting your work for consideration.

Log into the submission portal, select the “Make a New Submission” tab, select ”General Submissions,” and select “Panels” under “Presentation Formats.” To see the information you need to submit, view the sample submission form.

In particular, please be aware of these fields:

• A presentation format. To propose a Panel, please select Panels as your presentation format. You will then be taken to the forms specific to this presentation format. Please see below for more details about required information and materials for this presentation format.
• Unique emails per contributor are required.
• One representative image suitable for use on the conference website and in promotional materials. See the Representative Image Guidelines tab located on the Submission FAQ page.
• Abstract. The abstract should include what area you work in, what is novel about your work, how this work fits into existing work and brief biographies of each participant.The document you submit for review should be a single column PDF, which can be prepared in Microsoft Word or LaTeX – we recommend the use of LaTeX, and the “manuscript” parameter to the \documentclass will prepare the PDF as a one-column document:  \documentclass[manuscript]{acmart} If you are using Microsoft Word to prepare your submission, print the document to a PDF file

  This “submitted for review” PDF may be more than two pages in length.

  If accepted for presentation, the final PDF version of your documentation must be no more than two pages in length, including references, and will be generated in TAPS from your Microsoft Word or LaTeX source material.

  Abstracts should include authors’ names and affiliations, as the review process is “single blind.”

Panels are forums for experts in a particular area to have a guided, interactive dialogue with the audience about a specific topic. A good Panels submission proposes an interesting topic, identifies panelists who bring diverse opinions to the discussion, and outlines a proposed structure for the panel discussion itself. Good Panels do not rely on slides or a lot of prepared materials.

Examples of accepted content from past conferences, including Panels, have been made freely available by the ACM SIGGRAPH organization and can be accessed here.

Some reasons Panels proposals are rejected:

• The panel organizer has not confirmed specific speakers or has identified speakers but not clearly conveyed why those speakers are the best ones to address the proposed topic.
• The proposed panel topic is of very narrow interest and will only appeal to a very small number of participants.
• The proposed panel topic is too broad or not defined well enough to engender a focused discussion.
• The proposed panel lacks structure, or the structure fails to allow significant audience interaction. A panel that consists primarily of prepared statements by the panelists will be rejected.
• The jury believes the panelists do not offer sufficiently diverse viewpoints.

Jurors are asked to evaluate your submission using four criteria: concept, novelty, interest, and quality. The final submission score is based on a combination of these factors. For example, a high-quality panel that has broad appeal and is unlike other recent SIGGRAPH Panels has a good chance of acceptance, while a poorly motivated submission of interest to few attendees (or that duplicates recent panels) probably will be rejected.

Concept
How engaging and exceptional are the topics and voices presented in the Panel? How coherently does the submission convey its overall concept? If the theme is a historical one, do the concepts and viewpoints include new ideas and voices? For Panels in which the theme is not new, the submissions that include connections to new or future developments and some new voices will be evaluated more favorably by the jury.

Novelty
How new and fresh is this Panel? Is its topic new, or is it a fundamental computer graphics topic augmented with new developments? Are the panelists limited to pioneers in the field or have you also included new voices? Have you confirmed your panelists? Clearly communicate their qualifications and how their viewpoints vary. You must demonstrate to the jury that your proposal’s content and/or panelists are novel.

Interest
Will conference participants want to see this? Will it inspire them? Is the topic appealing to a broad audience? This is partly a measure of how broad the potential audience is and partly a measure of the timeliness of the submission.

Quality, Craft, and Completeness
How well written is the abstract? Who are the panelists and why were they selected? The abstract must effectively communicate the concept, Panel structure, and panelist information in enough detail and with enough clarity that the jury can evaluate the submission.

If your panel is accepted, the panel organizer must prepare and submit a revised abstract (two pages maximum). The two-page abstract should include an overview of the topics being discussed and brief biographies of each participant.

1. You will be notified of acceptance or rejection of your presentation in early May 2024. If your Panel is accepted, you will receive an email from “rightsreview@acm.org” with a link to your ACM Rights Management form within 72 hours of notification of acceptance of your work to the conference.Your representative image and text may be used for promotional purposes as several SIGGRAPH 2024 programs will prepare preview videos of accepted content for pre-conference promotion.
2. Complete Stage 2: Program Materials by Friday, 10 May 2024, which includes:
   1. Review your submission through the submission portal to confirm or update the list of contributors(s), affiliation(s), and 50-word summary statement suitable for conference publicity.
   2. Provide a valid ORCID identifier (ACM now requires that all accepted contributors register and provide ACM with valid ORCID identifiers prior to publication.) Corresponding contributors are responsible for collecting these ORCID identifiers from co-contributors and providing them to ACM as part of the ACM eRights selection process.You and your co-contributors can create and register your ORCID identifier at https://orcid.org/register. ACM only requires you to complete the initial ORCID registration process. However, ACM encourages you to take the additional step to claim ownership of all of your published works via the ORCID site.
3. Publication

   When your ACM Rights Management Form has been delivered to ACM, you will then receive an email from “tapsadmin@aptaracorp.awsapps.com” with information about the preparation and delivery of your material to TAPS for publication.Please note:

   • The Panel organizer is responsible for preparing and delivering the two-page abstract to TAPS.
   • Each Panel participant will be sent their own rights form to complete. The organizer cannot complete one form on behalf of all of the participants – this is ACM policy.

   Please make sure that emails from “rightsreview@acm.org” and “tapsadmin@aptaracorp.awsapps.com” are part of the “allow list” in your email program, so that you do not miss these email messages.

   The source (Word or LaTeX) of your abstract, as well as any supplemental materials, must be delivered to TAPS, ACM’s article production system. TAPS will generate the PDF and HTML5 versions of your abstract for publication in the ACM Digital Library. The TAPS-generated PDF of your abstract must be no more than two pages in length, including references.

   You must deliver your material to TAPS, resolve any formatting issues identified by TAPS or by the proceedings production editor, and approve your material for publication by Friday, 17 May 2024. If you cannot meet that deadline, you will not be allowed to present your material at SIGGRAPH 2024.

   Information about the preparation and delivery of your final material to TAPS also can be found at https://homes.cs.washington.edu/~spencer/taps/taps.html.

4. In-Person Presentations

   If your Panel is accepted, the panelist must:

   • Only present accepted, jury-reviewed content. Presenting new content is not allowed.
   • Attend and present your Panel in-person at SIGGRAPH 2024 in Denver.
   • Contributors should plan to present from their own personal laptops. SIGGRAPH will provide the adapters needed to connect personal computers to the session projector.

   Please note: Panels are anchored by people and discussion, not presentations. Panels should not rely on PowerPoint slides, video clips, or other visual materials.

5. Presenter Recognition

   Contributor Registration Benefit: Up to six contributors per accepted Panel receive a 25% discount on Full Conference registration.To present your Panel at SIGGRAPH 2024, contributor must be registered at the Full Conference registration level.

   You will receive an email by early June explaining how to access the registration discount code as well as instructions for registering. The contributors using the discount code are eligible for the early-bird registration rate regardless of when registration is completed. Any additional contributors who will be presenting the Panel are required to register at the appropriate registration level for the program, and prevailing registration rates will apply.

21 February 2024, 22:00 UTC/GMT
Submission deadline.

Early May 2024
Acceptance or rejection notices are sent to all submitters.

10 May 2024
Deadline to make any changes to materials (i.e., approved title changes, contributors names, descriptions) for publication on the website.

17 May 2024
Two-page abstract deadline. If we do not receive your two-page abstract by 17 May, you will not be allowed to present at SIGGRAPH 2024.

26 July 2024
Official publication date for the ACM Digital Library

Please Note: The official publication date is the date the proceedings are made available in the ACM Digital Library. This date may be up to two weeks prior to the first day of your conference. The official publication date affects the deadline for any patent filings related to published work. (For those rare conferences whose proceedings are published in the ACM Digital Library after the conference is over, the official publication date remains the first day of the conference.)

28 July–1 August 2024
SIGGRAPH 2024
Colorado Convention Center
Denver, Colorado